Auto Darkening Welding Helmets vs Passive – Which is Best?

A good quality helmet is a must for any welder, whether a person is a professional or pursuing welding as a hobby. Even if you weld every now and then, a good quality helmet will give you peace of mind in knowing that your eyes are safe from the arc’s glow. With a quality helmet, you will be able to work faster and with more confidence too.

Many welders are unable to decide from auto-darkening welding helmets vs passive welding helmets. They often have questions which helmet is the best for their use and which helmet will give them the best value for their money in the long run.

In this article, we are going to take a look at the advantages and disadvantages of auto-darkening welding helmets vs. passive helmets and figure out which helmets are best suited for which kind of users. Keep in mind, before making the final decision on any kind of helmet, make sure you wear it and check if it is comfortable and you can freely move while wearing the helmet.

What are Auto Darkening Welding Helmets

Aut-Darkening Welding Helmets Darken Instantly On detecting the Arc

Auto-darkening helmets, as the name suggests, darken upon detecting the presence of the arc. This is especially useful for welders who do not want to take their helmet off while welding. The auto-darkening helmets have screens that are made of LCD and these screens are powered by a battery or a solar panel. Some helmet models have screens that are powered by a combination of battery and solar panel. Once you wear the helmet, you will be able to see the project clearly as the shade is at level 3 or 4 depending on the model of the helmet. As soon as the arc is switched on, the helmet detects the arc in milliseconds, and the lens turns dark.

Welders can further adjust the sensitivity and delay of the auto-darkening helmet thus giving them a wider range of flexibility when working on a difficult project. These helmets are also useful when working outdoors as the welder does not need to remove the helmet to inspect the project.

Advantages of Auto-Darkening Welding Helmets

Let’s take a quick look at some advantages of auto-darkening welding helmets.

  1. Auto-Darkening Lens – The lens of the helmet darkens instantly on detection of the arc. This feature adds to the safety as even accidental activation of the arc can darken the helmet.
  2. Visibility While Inactive – While the lens is inactive, it is easy to see through it and the welder does not need to take the helmet off to inspect the project he is working on.
  3. Stability – The helmet is stable on the welder’s head and as there is no need to take it on and off, one can work quickly and efficiently.
  4. Better Control on the Torch – When the welder is able to see the welding torch without taking off the helmet, it allows better manipulation of the flame. The welder does not need to move the helmet to adjust his view after switching off the torch as the viewing window clears up once the arc is switched off.

Disadvantages of Auto-Darkening Welding Helmets

Auto-darkening helmets are not without their faults. Here’s a quick look at some of the disadvantages of auto-darkening helmets.

  1. Limited Lens Adjustment – Certain models of auto-darkening helmets come with limited ADF range that doesn’t allow variation or adjustment beyond a certain range. The shade is fixed at 10 when the arc is active and 3-4 when the arc is switched off. This prevents the user from working on welding projects that require variation in shade. If users plan to work on different kind of welding projects they should look for helmets that allow shade adjustment.
  2. Expensive – Auto-darkening helmets use advanced technology that can be expensive to maintain and repair in the long run. The initial cost of entry for auto-darkening helmets makes them an investment that some people often think twice about. As most of these helmets require batteries to function, you will need to keep spare batteries at hand in case the helmet runs out of power while working.
  3. Weight – The auto-darkening helmets contain heavy parts as they provide protection to the eyes, head, and neck. The heavy weight of some of these helmets can make them cumbersome to wear while working for long hours. It is important to test a helmet by wearing if before you buy it.

What are Passive Welding Helmets

Passive Welding Helmets Offer Limited Shade Adjustment

Passive welding helmets have a fixed shade lens that cannot be adjusted. Most of the passive welding helmets have a fixed shade of 10 and the lens of the helmet is coated with Infrared and Ultraviolet protection to safeguard the welder’s eyes from the glare of the arc. The helmets are often held in hand or worn on the forehead and used when the arc is active, and the welder has to take the helmet off to inspect the welding project.

Advantages of passive welding helmets

Even if there are no advanced electronics in the passive welding helmets, there are several advantages of these helmets. Let’s take a look at some of these advantages.

  1. Affordable – The passive helmets are much more affordable compared to auto-darkening welding helmets as there are fewer parts and the parts that are used for making them are not that expensive.
  2. Lightweight – These helmets are lightweight and easy to handle as there are no complex parts or batteries to give them weight. The welders can hold a helmet in one hand and easily work on the arc with the other hand.
  3. Smaller Size – Compared to auto-darkening welding helmets, the passive helmets are smaller in size which makes it easier to work with these helmets in cramped spaces or areas where it is difficult to move around too much.
  4. Easy to Repair – The passive welding helmets are easy to repair as there aren’t too many moving parts. In case something is wrong with the lens, you can simply change it for continued operation.

Disadvantages of Passive Welding Helmets

With their simple features, there are some disadvantages to welding helmets as well. Let’s take a quick look at some of these disadvantages.

  1. Limited Adjustment – The shade level on the passive helmets is fixed to the level of 10, and there is no scope of adjustment if the welder wants to work on a different kind of welding task.
  2. Limited Protection – If you are working on different kinds of welding projects, you need to make sure that you have the right shade of lenses for the project. Not having the right shade of lenses in your passive helmet can result in an injury.
  3. Manual Positioning – The helmet needs to be manually positioned in place while working which can lead to distraction and accidents while working.

Auto-darkening Helmets or Passive Helmets – which helmet is best?

If you are looking for a welding helmet for your welding projects, then it is the best idea to go with an auto-darkening welding helmet. It might cost you more than a passive helmet, but the level of protection offered by an auto-darkening helmet is the best in class. The helmet offers protection from arc flares, and you can use it on multiple welding projects with ease. There is also no risk of accidental exposure to the arc flash as the helmet can turn dark instantaneously.

Conclusion

The answer to which type of helmet is best is simple. The auto-darkening helmet provides more value for money and also offers added safety features that will help you in working with peace of mind in knowing that you are safe from the arc flash.

Whether you are a professional welder or a hobbyist welder, at no point should you take a risk with the safety while welding. Keeping the advantages of the auto-darkening helmets in mind, it is the best idea to go with these helmets from a reputed brand.

If you have any questions or queries about welding helmets, please feel free to discuss in the comment section.

Image Sources: 1